A parent asked me: “Why does she listen to you and not me?”

Alex L Bio

Having been a teacher for many years, I never cease to feel for parents when they are struggling with their child. It’s hard for them and, also, hard to witness. 

When Tasmin asked me this question I really wanted to help her. Sumatra, her daughter, was doing well at nursery – she generally understood what we asked of her and complied.

One day at pick-up time, Tasmin approached me.

Our conversation 

Tasmin:  Did you see that? Sumatra just did what you asked her to do. She won’t listen to me. 

Alex: Ah yes. It’s far trickier when you’re a parent. It was the same when my children were little. 

Tasmin: So, why does she listen to you and not me? 

Alex: Well, firstly, the children don’t always listen – I have the same problem as you! 

Tasmin laughs: Oh good, I’m glad it’s not just me

Alex: Definitely not – but we can talk about ways that may help you if that would be useful? As teachers, we learn about these things in our training.

Tasmin: Yes please - that’d be really helpful. 

Alex: Well today, I could see that Sumatra was really enjoying the slide. When it was nearly time to stop, I gave her a 5-minute warning. This is a way of preparing her that time’s nearly up. Sometimes we use a timer so that the children can see the 5 minutes ticking down.

Tasmin: Oh, that sounds like a good thing to do - could you tell me exactly how you told her about the 5 minutes she had left?  

Alex: Firstly, I got her attention and then said, “Sumatra, in 5 minutes you’ll need to come inside with everyone else. Do you want two more turns on the slide or three?” She chose three.

Tasmin: Yes, I see - she knew her playtime was running out and had time to adjust. So, you avoided just suddenly taking her away from what she was enjoying. 

Alex: Exactly, although sometimes children can still be upset, even with that time to adjust. It’s OK though, and we can acknowledge it. 

Tasmin: How would you do that?

Alex: I’d say something like “I know it is hard to stop playing on the slide and you’re a little sad and angry. You can have another turn tomorrow”

Tasmin: Oh yes, so that she knows she can return to the slide. Did Sumatra stop today?

Alex: Yes, she did, I supported her by counting down her turns, three more, two more, one more! I then took her hand and praised her, “You listened, you were a little sad, but you came off the slide. Well done, Sumatra!”

Tasmin: What would you do if she cried?

Alex: It’s important to be consistent, so I’d calmly acknowledge her feelings but continue to support her to come off the slide. “I can see you’re enjoying yourself, but it is time to stop now. Let’s go.”

Tasmin: Thank you. I’ll try that idea at home.

Alex: Let’s have a chat in a couple of weeks and see how it’s going? 

Our follow-up conversation  

Two weeks later, I caught up with Tasmin to see how things were going:

Alex: So Tasmin, how are things going at home? Have you been able to try the strategy we talked about?

Tasmin: Yes, mostly it’s been going well. I used it to prepare for stopping playing when it was time to get ready for bed. 

Alex: Yes, it’s a great idea to focus on just one routine to begin with - bedtime is an ideal one. 

Tasmin: Yes, that’s what I thought. It felt manageable.

Tasmin: It’s usually when I forget and then get a bit annoyed, trying to rush. I’m certainly learning the importance of staying calm, though, and having clear expectations.

Alex: I agree - trying to be calm and consistent is key as we help children to cope with behavioural expectations and boundaries. 

Tasmin: I’ll keep working on it and try using the strategy at other transition times too.

Alex: Keep up the good work (laughs) and let’s check in again in a fortnight.

Alex: Feeling manageable is crucial. It’s good to hear that you’re both making progress. You said it’s mostly going well – do you want to say a bit about when it doesn’t go so well?

I am so pleased that things seem to be working out for Tasmin and Sumatra. Empowering parents to support self-regulation is an important aspect of our work as educators in the early years. 

The EEF guidance resource How to empower parents to support children’s self-regulation states that early years educators should guide parents to test out one simple strategy at a time. They explicitly advocate ‘a consistent approach to boundaries, so children know what to expect and parents trust their own judgement in how to respond.’

I feel that this is suggestion is working for Tasmin, and she feels the same. We’ll continue to work together for as long as she needs. 

Questions for reflection 

  1. What could you do to help a child prepare for a transition rather than expecting them to stop an enjoyable activity straight away?
  2. How do you acknowledge a child’s feelings during a difficult moment while maintaining a clear boundary?

 

Want to know more?

 Education Endowment Foundation (2024): How to empower parents to support children’s self-regulation. 

Dix, P (2024): When the Parents Change, Everything Changes: seismic shifts in children’s behaviour. Penguin Books UK.