A needs-led system: A response to the Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism.

Caroline Vollans 2026

“There should be a fundamental shift from a ‘diagnosis-dependent’ system to a ‘needs-led plus diagnosis’ system.” (Recommendation 2: p6) 

What if children and families could receive meaningful support as soon as difficulties emerge - without always needing a diagnosis first? 

That possibility lies at the heart of a major independent review chaired by Professor Peter Fonagy, a leading clinical psychologist and psychoanalyst.

The 599-page report was published on 9 October this year: The Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism. 

Perhaps the most striking recommendation that Fonagy and his team make is a shift from a system where support follows diagnosis to one where support is provided much earlier, as soon as a person’s needs emerge. 

In evidence to the parliamentary Health and Social Care Committee, Fonagy described his proposed change as:

“A shift from a diagnosis-led system, where people have to wait to get a diagnosis in order to get support, to a system where, as soon as they present with a need, that need gets addressed and they are then prioritised for a diagnosis if needed.” 

(Oral evidence: Children and Young People's Mental Health, Wednesday 14 October 2026.)

It would be a more integrated system in which people can access support through different routes, without being passed between services or having to meet a diagnostic threshold first. For example, a parent might raise concerns with a health visitor. Those concerns should lead to meaningful support rather than simply another referral and another wait.

Fonagy does not argue against diagnosis. He maintains that diagnosis is ‘essential’ and needs protecting. His proposed system does not mean overlooking children with the most significant needs, for whom diagnosis remains important. 

What, then, is the particular significance of this needs-led approach for early years practice?

Identifying early need

The review makes clear that professionals do not have to know precisely what is causing the person’s difficulties before they begin to offer support. 

Educators in the early years are no strangers to recognising emerging needs, even though doing so is not straightforward. Children’s needs are complex and can present in different ways. 

It’s worth highlighting an important caveat here. Fonagy’s report is emphatic that his needs-led approach, using observations and informal assessment, does not replace specialist assessment. Nor must it become a reason to dilute or delay specialist provision.

An integral part of daily practice, educators in the early years may observe a child who struggles to communicate, finds transitions and change very difficult, becomes easily distressed in noisy environments, has difficulty regulating their emotions or finds it hard to engage in play or interact with other children.

Recognising these difficulties and intervening early to support the child are already familiar aspects of early years practice. 

Such support might include:

  • observing the child’s development
  • identifying emerging difficulties
  • supporting communication and language
  • promoting emotional regulation
  • building secure relationships
  • working with parents and carers
  • making adaptations to the learning environment
  • seeking advice from other professionals

This kind of early identification and response is also reflected in wider proposals for SEND reform.

Areas of development: moving away from areas of need

The Government’s 2026 White Paper, Every Child Achieving and Thriving, proposes moving away from the ‘areas of need’ outlined in the SEND code of practice. Instead, the reformed system will introduce ‘areas of development’ that reflect key aspects of child development. 

This approach recognises that areas of development are relevant to all children and moves the focus away from a deficit-based view of children, which focuses on what they cannot do. 

The Department for Education argues that: 

‘These areas must move us away from the categorisation of children and an increasing reliance on diagnosis, which may hide nuance and individual difference in barriers to learning and participation. Instead, the areas of development will support early and dynamic needs-led provision, enabling educators to recognise and respond to the educational needs that are likely to present in a classroom or setting, described in terms that they know and understand.’ (SEND reform: putting children and young people first)

The Under 5 gap

Although Fonagy’s report includes the 0–5 age group in its data, under-fives do not receive the same level of attention as school-age children and adolescents. This raises a question about the extent to which the review’s commitment to prevention and early support addresses the needs of babies and young children. 

In the early years we know that: 

  • Early intervention matters: difficulties experienced in infancy and early childhood can have consequences that persist throughout life.
  • Services need to work together: Health visitors, GPs, midwives, social care, early years education and mental health professionals all have a role to play.

The challenge for the early years sector is to secure earlier access to specialist support and better collaboration across services.

The Early Years sector has long recognised the importance of the first five years of life, understanding how relationships, communication, emotional security, play and the environment shape children's development.

But recognition is not enough. There is a difference between identifying a child's needs and having the resources, expertise and services available to respond to them. Identification of need must be followed by intervention – families cannot be kept waiting. 

If the Fonagy Review is proposing a fundamental shift towards a needs-led system, what will this mean in practice for the early years? 

Will early years educators have better access to specialist advice? Will families receive support earlier? Will health, education and social care services work together more effectively?

And, crucially, will there be the resources and workforce capacity to make this happen?

Identifying need is only meaningful if support follows.